Sunday, September 25, 2011

The C in D.C: The Politics of Death

Calling D.C a 'political city' is an understatement. Knowing it is the center of all things bureaucratic, legislative and municipal is much more like it.The Districts veins ebb and flow with the political jargon of lobbyists, Congressmen and women, Senators, Representatives and the ever present hopeful intern, faithfully trailing along the way, trying to grasp every name and duty thrown their way.Not only is it the home of all three branches of American Government, but also the place of change and civic rebellion of the status quo. Dred Scott v. Sandford, Plessy v. Ferguson, Roe vs. Wade - the list of notable Supreme Court decisions is ceaseless. History is a testament to that.

And now, so is this week.

For two decades, the case of Troy Davis has resounded in the South and slowly but surely made its unjust presence known throughout the country and the world. On August 19, 1989 a trivial argument over a can of beer between a friend of Davis' and a homeless man ended in the shooting and murder of Mark MacPhail who was working as a security guard at Burger King. Troy was convicted in '91 of his murder and sentenced to death by execution. Though witnesses at the time claimed they saw Davis shoot MacPhail, and incidentally the homeless man as well, time has since changed 7 of the 9 key witnesses stories, and they now claim Davis is innocent of the shootings. The police never found a murder weapon, obtained physical evidence or DNA from the scene; their entire case revolved around testimony - now completely inadmissible - and matching bullet casings from a prior shooting Davis was convicted of. The myriad of facts are seemingly regardless now; the overall lack of evidence, his original lackluster attorneys, the four scheduled and then cancelled execution dates, the countless appeals and court proceedings, the massive continual outcry of injustice and inhumanity. All the matters now is that on Monday, September 19th the State of Georgia scheduled a hearing for Davis' 2nd clemency hearing. On Tuesday it was denied. And by Wednesday, after heart stopping last minute Supreme Court deliberation to review Davis' stay of execution request was denied, Troy Davis was indeed executed at 11:08 pm in the state of Georgia.

Though some would say that Davis was guilty, some would conversely say he was innocent and others among us may simply not care about a would-be criminal of any sort locked away on death row. However, Troy Davis and his case were anything but typical. The supreme lack of evidence, both then and unsought after now, is the key to the universal disparity and applicability of this case. Anyone who should so happen to be in the wrong place at the wrong time accosted by a mob mentality of pointing the finger at any sacrificial lamb who appears to be guilty could be the next Troy Davis. Any man or woman, in the state of Georgia or outside of it, can be accused and convicted of a heinous crime such as callous murder should a mere few of the many factors needed in a civic court of law just so happen to line up and earn you a conviction, consider yourself Troy Davis. And when a seemingly sophisticated circuit of the highest courts in our society throw the book at you and sentence you to the barbaric and inhumane ledge of execution, despite obvious objection and with every inkling of doubt amid it's decision - then everyone of us has the opportunity to be Troy Davis. Injustice reared its ugly unlawful head this week - we all got a long and through look.

Now living in D.C perhaps I was made more aware of the proceedings going on both here and in Georgia because of the role of the Supreme Court, and it's proximity to my backyard. As a student at one of the most politically active Black colleges, my peers and I spread the word and others marched to the White House. Though Troy himself cannot be saved, the world knows his name and will never forget. And ambitiously speaking, this should never happen again. Please, let his story be a testament to that.

1 comment:

Anonymous said...

The death penalty is inherently unequal and racist in its execution (word play!). Far more minorities, especially African-Americans and immigrants (especially illegal immigrants), are sentenced to death for crimes that their Caucasian counterparts are not - same crime, different punishments. Take, for example, this case: http://www.reuters.com/article/2008/05/22/us-usa-execution-idUSN2250765020080522
This man, an admitted (albeit, "apologetic"....) killer, had his sentence commuted to life in prison. He admitted to the brutal beating and murder of a shop owner, but was allowed to live. Troy Davis has proclaimed his innocence since the beginning and has never had a shred of physical evidence admitted that proves the contrary. Even if he weren't freed, and his conviction upheld, he still should not have been sentenced TO DEATH for a crime we are not 100% sure he committed.

While I'm in favor of abolishing the death penalty for a multitude of reasons, I can't see why we haven't been able to reach a compromise - execute serial killers, mass murderers, psychopath, horrible people who have done horrible things, when the evidence is overwhelming,etc. But to sentence someone to death over something like this, when life in prison has the same effect - keeping dangerous criminals off the streets (for a much lower cost to the public!) - it seems, to me, that we (society) are losing our respect for life just like the murders.

On a side note, I think it's completely barbaric, inhuman, and monstrous to allow people to witness the execution of another human being. Their hands may not be the one injecting, but their eyes witness the event in the same way as the nurses (not doctors, doctor's cannot administer lethal injections) who perform the execution.

I have a lot to say about this....maybe I will blog about it...untimely, of course.